Being a fish parent, in our opinion, has both benefits and drawbacks. It’s never simple to choose a fish species since there are so many to choose from, yet not all of them can coexist. As a result, most fish parents grapple with the subject of “can betta fish live with goldfish?” since these two are the most popular.
Although betta fish and goldfish may coexist, it is not recommended owing to their varied environmental needs. Furthermore, they have distinct nutritional needs, making feeding them in the same tank a challenge. Goldfish are regarded as “dirty fish” because they create a lot of waste, which causes ammonia levels to rise, which might harm your betta.
Because of their appearance, betta fish are quite popular. This species was popular for keeping because of its vibrant colors and edgy personality. They don’t get along with many other fish, though, because of their disposition. You’ll most likely assume your new betta needs some companionship when you first receive it.
Goldfish are among the most popular aquarium fish. Goldfish, on the other hand, may not be the best companion for your betta. These two species can cohabit in certain situations, but there are a lot of factors to consider before determining whether or not that’s the right fit for you.
Despite the fact that both goldfish and betta are tough fish, keeping them in the same tank may not be the greatest option. We’ll explain all you need to know about the differences. In addition, we’ll discuss how betta and goldfish can coexist, despite the fact that this isn’t the ideal option.
Is it possible to keep Betta Fish and Goldfish together?
Yes, betta fish and goldfish may coexist, but there are certain considerations to make before putting them in the same tank. This essay will go over all you need to know before determining whether or not you want to keep them together.
Goldfish vs. Betta Fish
The only thing that bettas and goldfish have in common is that they are both amiable and like interacting with people. We’ll go through a detailed comparison of goldfish and betta fish in this post to help you understand what makes them so distinct. Hopefully, you’ll be able to determine if betta fish and goldfish can coexist.
Basics of Betta Fish
The betta fish, often known as the Siamese fighting fish, is a member of the Osphronemidae family. Bettas are tropical fish that originate in Southeast Asia. Despite the fact that there are 73 different varieties of betta fish, the majority are hybridized (bred in captivity), resulting in spectacular colors and fins that are prized by fish owners.
The natural population of betta fish lives in Thailand’s Chao Phraya and Mekong river basins. Bettas like shallow, slow-moving waterways such as floodplains, marshes, and rice paddles. “Labyrinth breathers” are what they’re called. Bettas have evolved a special respiratory mechanism that allows them to swallow air from the surface.
They can live in waters with low oxygen levels due to dry seasons because of this remarkable organ. Bettas are thought to be able to survive in tiny bowls or tanks due to an evolutionary quirk that allows them to capture air from the surface, however, this is not the case. Bettas need a tank with at least two gallons of water, as well as heating, lighting, and filtration.
The Fundamentals of Goldfish
Goldfish are so popular that they may be found in practically any pet shop on the planet. Goldfish have a Central Asian ancestor known as the wild Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio). There are around 125 different varieties of goldfish, all of which are bred in captivity.
Slow-moving waterways, such as rivers, ponds, lakes, and ditches, are also ideal for goldfish. Unfortunately, most goldfish owners, like captive bettas, confine their pets in tiny tanks or bowls with ineffective filtering systems. Goldfish, in particular, suffer from a lack of filtration since they create enormous volumes of waste.
See also Can Guppy Fish Live In A Bowl? – Complete Info By Pets Bent
Expected Life Expectancy
Apart from wondering whether a goldfish and a betta can cohabit, fish owners are interested in learning more about their longevity. The answer varies greatly depending on the species, but in general, bigger fish live considerably longer than smaller ones. Furthermore, animals that give birth to live younglings survive for a shorter period of time than those that lay eggs.
Even though bettas and goldfish are two of the most popular fish to keep as pets, their lifespans are vastly different. Betta fish may live for up to four years, whereas goldfish can live for up to two decades. Betta’s longevity is determined by the environment in which they reside, and they may live a long life if their nutrition is well monitored and the tank is kept clean.
Goldfish have a life that is entirely opposite that of humans. There have been multiple reports of goldfish surviving for more than 25 years. Goldfish are a great illustration of how a bad tank environment shortens a fish’s lifetime. Unfortunately, most pet goldfish will die if they are kept in an unsuitable setting.
Furthermore, if goldfish do not get the attention they need, their longevity will be limited to a few years. As a result, do all you can to assist them in living a long life so that you may both enjoy each other’s company for a long time.
Diet
Bettas are carnivores, which means they consume meat and need a lot of protein, unlike goldfish, who are omnivores. Goldfish, being omnivores, love to consume both meat and vegetables.
Feeding your betta goldfish food or vice versa may have disastrous consequences since it has a considerable impact on your pet’s health. Betta fish appreciate plants in the aquarium, although they seldom contact or consume them. Goldfish, on the other hand, will consume certain plants that they find in your tank.
Temperament
Bettas have a single rule when it comes to their temperament: everything that swims is my enemy! There are a few outliers, such as the Otocinclus catfish (Otocinclus affinis) and several tetra species.
Bettas have been known to attack fellow bettas, but they will also attack most other fish. To solve this problem, divide the tank in half and isolate your betta from other fish.
Goldfish, unlike bettas, are very calm fish that swim happily among other species. That is one of the reasons why many people choose to maintain goldfish over other types of fish. Keep in mind that goldfish are omnivores, so don’t put them in a tank with little fish that they may eat.
Habitat
Goldfish and betta fish enjoy distinct styles of aquarium décor, thus the same aquarium décor will not please both of them. Bettas like a densely planted aquarium with plenty of hiding places and resting spots, while goldfish prefer an open tank with plenty of areas to swim.
If you’re still unsure if betta fish and goldfish may live together, bear in mind that although plenty of rocks, plants, and driftwood may be excellent décor and habitat for your betta, it’s not at all appealing to goldfish. Being a caring fish mom entails attending to all of your pet’s requirements.
Flow of Water
A goldfish aquarium necessitates a high-quality filtration system capable of effectively cleaning the water in your aquarium so that your goldfish may live in a healthy environment. Such filtering systems will produce a very powerful water flow that is unsuitable for your betta fish.
Bettas, being little fish compared to goldfish, have a difficult time swimming, which is why they prefer a very low current or no current at all. A mild bubbling sponge filter that will function well in a betta aquarium should be considered.
The temperature of the water in which you will be living
Even though bettas look to be robust fish, don’t be fooled by their appearance into thinking they can withstand extreme temperatures. Bettas demand water temperatures of 75° to 85° F since they are tropical fish. Please keep in mind that any temperature outside of this range will cause your betta to get stressed or perhaps die.
See also Do Guppies Need Light? – A Complete Info By PetsBent
Goldfish, on the other hand, are mostly cold-water fish that thrive in water temperatures ranging from 65 to 75 degrees Fahrenheit. Goldfish, on the other hand, will not suffer if their water temperature falls outside of this range. If you consider all that has been said so far, the answer to the question “can betta fish live with goldfish” should be obvious. Dietary, health, and environmental needs are extremely different for both species. As a result, mixing them in the same tank is not a good idea.
The cleanliness of the water
There’s one more thing to consider before deciding if goldfish and betta fish can coexist in the same aquarium. It’s all about aquarium sanitation. Goldfish are notorious for being unclean. It’s not about their manners; goldfish don’t have stomachs, so they excrete a lot of waste, which raises ammonia levels.
Despite their toughness, bettas are vulnerable to ammonia sickness. Your betta might die fast if it is poisoned. Aside from ammonia poisoning, there’s another hazard to be aware of.
Because goldfish excrete a lot of waste, your aquarium will need to be cleaned and changed often. All of this may have a negative impact on your betta’s health since it is quite stressful and can weaken their immune system.
As a result, you’ll have to determine if you want to risk your betta’s ammonia poisoning by not cleaning your tank on a regular basis. Cleaning it often, on the other hand, can stress your betta, causing severe immune system issues.
There is a solution to this problem, although it isn’t ideal. Cleaning your tank is possible, but not recommended. In such a situation, you’ll need a robust filter to aid in the reduction of ammonia levels. Even while goldfish don’t mind heavy filtration, your betta will almost certainly struggle to swim, which will likely upset your pet.
Tank Size and Living Conditions
Bettas are tiny species that grow to be between 2 and 3 inches long when fully grown. As a result, giving your betta a 10-gallon tank will make it a very happy (but still furious) fish since it will have plenty of room to swim, hide, and relax.
Even though bettas are little, it’s not a good idea to keep them in a small bowl since they love to explore their surroundings. You can keep your betta in a 2-gallon tank at the very least. A 5 or 10-gallon aquarium, on the other hand, will make your tropical fish a lot happy companion.
When it comes to goldfish, some of them may easily grow to be 6 inches long or even more. If you just have one goldfish, you’ll need a 20-gallon aquarium, plus an extra 10 gallons for each additional goldfish in the same tank.
Furthermore, plants in a tank with goldfish will not last long since goldfish may be rather destructive. They usually uproot the plants and rummage through the substrate for any leftover food remnants.
Is Keeping Betta Fish and Goldfish Together Worth It?
What kind of fish may coexist with bettas?
If you consider all that has been said so far, the answer to the question “can betta fish live with goldfish” should be obvious. Dietary, health and environmental needs are extremely different for both species. As a result, mixing them in the same tank is not a good idea.
There’s a popular assumption that goldfish adapt to their environment, and this is somewhat accurate. However, this is not a good thing since it would reduce their lifetime and make them more prone to numerous ailments. To summarize, it is not a compassionate approach to care for your pet.
Is it Possible to Keep Your Betta and Goldfish Together in the Short Term?
Let’s say there’s an emergency, such as a filtration system failure. Your goldfish and betta may theoretically coexist in the same tank for a day or two until the filter is replaced. You should acquire a quarantine tank and temporarily relocate your fish there if you want to prevent stress and dangerous situations. Will a goldfish be killed by a betta fish?
See also How Long Do Guppies Live? (Some Tips For Long Life)
There’s a popular assumption that goldfish adapt to their environment, and this is somewhat accurate. However, this is not a good thing since it would reduce their lifetime and make them more prone to numerous ailments. To summarize, it is not a compassionate approach to care for your pet.
Is it Possible to Keep Your Betta and Goldfish Together in the Short Term?
Let’s say there’s an emergency, such as a filtration system failure. Your goldfish and betta may theoretically coexist in the same tank for a day or two until the filter is replaced. You should acquire a quarantine tank and temporarily relocate your fish there if you want to prevent stress and dangerous situations.
FAQs
Will a goldfish be killed by a betta fish?
A betta fish will not kill a goldfish, and the two may coexist. However, there are a variety of reasons why these two fish should not be kept in the same tank that you should be aware of.
Are goldfish and betta fish compatible?
No, goldfish and betta fish are incompatible for a variety of reasons. It’s not so much about their personality as it is about the many habitat settings they have experienced, among other factors.
Is it possible for betta fish to consume goldfish food?
Yes, betta fish can consume goldfish food and digest it without issue; however, don’t give your betta goldfish food too often. Bettas need a lot of protein in their diet, and goldfish food will not provide it.
Is it possible to feed goldfish betta fish food?
Yes, goldfish can eat betta fish, but only in little amounts and infrequently. Despite the fact that betta fish food is a healthy source of protein for your goldfish, it may cause renal failure, swim bladder infection, and intestinal gas due to the goldfish digestive tract’s tiny size and inability to digest significant amounts of protein-rich diets.
Check Out This: Can Betta Fish Live in Tap Water?
Conclusion
Can Betta Fish Live With Goldfish? As you can see, betta fish and goldfish may potentially coexist in the same aquarium. Even so, there are a lot of things to be aware of and a lot of difficulties to overcome. Even if you feel you can handle everything, juggling all of these tasks at the same time will definitely be hard.
More significantly, it’s potentially dangerous for your pets. Putting betta fish and goldfish in the same aquarium is a no-no. Rather, obtain two suitable tanks and place them in their ideal habitats. They’re both fantastic, and they’d make wonderful pets. Have you made up your mind on which one is ideal for you and which pet fish you’ll get?
